In a historic move poised to reshape the gem and jewellery industry, the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) has announced it will discontinue the traditional 4Cs grading system—cut, colour, clarity, and carat weight—for lab-grown diamonds (LGDs) by the end of 2025. Instead, GIA will introduce a simplified descriptive classification system, broadly categorizing LGDs as ‘Premium’ or ‘Standard’, with no grade assigned to diamonds falling below minimum quality thresholds.
Why This Change?
According to GIA, the shift is intended to enhance consumer understanding and promote greater transparency in an increasingly complex gemstone marketplace. While lab-grown diamonds share identical chemical and physical properties with natural diamonds, their origin and emotional symbolism differ significantly.
By moving away from the 4Cs framework, GIA aims to clearly distinguish LGDs from natural diamonds, reducing the potential for consumer confusion and reinforcing the unique identity and geological rarity of natural stones.
India Responds: Industry Leaders Applaud the Decision
As one of the world’s leading centers for both natural and lab-grown diamond manufacturing, India has responded positively to the change.
Kirit Bhansali, Chairman of the Gem & Jewellery Export Promotion Council (GJEPC), praised the announcement:
“GIA’s decision to replace the 4Cs with descriptive grading for lab-grown diamonds is a significant evolution. It eliminates ambiguity, allows for clear differentiation, and fosters transparency and trust across the industry.”
Ashok Gajera, Managing Director of Laxmi Diamonds, echoed these sentiments, stating that the move encourages a more accurate understanding of LGDs as a distinct product category.
“Unlike natural diamonds, which take billions of years to form deep within the Earth, lab-grown diamonds are created in a matter of weeks. This reclassification is essential, especially for Indian consumers who associate GIA certification with authenticity and long-term value.”
Market Implications: A Shift in Perception and Practice
The redefinition comes at a time when lab-grown diamonds are gaining traction for their affordability, ethical sourcing, and sustainable appeal. However, using the same grading language for both LGDs and natural diamonds has led to market confusion around pricing, resale value, and perceived worth.
Amit Pratihari of De Beers India commended the move:
“GIA’s decision is a timely and important move that brings much-needed clarity to consumers. This decision reaffirms the emotional and geological uniqueness of natural diamonds, which cannot be replicated in a lab.”
Henry Smith of the Institute of Diamonds added:
“From a scientific perspective, the change is both logical and necessary. Natural and lab-grown diamonds have distinct origins and growth patterns; they should not be evaluated by the same standards.”
A New Global Standard
While GIA’s revised approach may forgo some technical granularity, it delivers enhanced clarity and consumer relevance by recognising the distinct value narratives of natural and lab-grown diamonds. This move is likely to influence other gemological laboratories, encouraging the adoption of similar models and paving the way for greater global standardisation in grading practices. Notably, only a small fraction of lab-grown diamonds are currently certified by GIA, indicating significant potential for broader adoption and harmonisation across the industry.
Coexistence Through Clarity
GIA’s landmark decision marks a pivotal moment in the diamond industry. By acknowledging the scientific reality and market evolution, the institute is enabling natural and lab-grown diamonds to coexist, each with its own clear identity and value proposition.
This shift not only reinforces the distinct prestige of natural diamonds but also validates lab-grown diamonds as a viable, transparent choice for the modern consumer.
To stay updated with the latest developments in the gems and jewellery industry, click here.
